Wed, 13 Jan 2010
Airport Extreme Shenanigans
I recently got my hands on an Airport Extreme from Apple. It's a nice little device to replace my old linksys. I was using my Soekris board to do that but something which speaks AFP natively is nice to have, especially now that I have 2 Apple machines in the house. Have no fear, my Soekris box will still be my border device, and will run a couple of key services too.
While configuring the Airport to replace my Linksys I was unable to find a way to set the internal IP address of the device. I can tell it to use NAT or just bridge at layer 2. If it is in NAT mode I can't tell it what to use for an internal IP address, at all. It defaults to 10.0.1.1, 192.168.1.1 or 172.something.1.1. This totally screws up my network, and AFAICT there is no way to change it, at least after spending 10 minutes looking through their administration stuff and online.
Back when I learned networking basics your default gateway lived at the top of the network address space, and I've always configured my networks to be like that. I understand that it doesn't have to be that way, but it's just the way I've rolled for as long as I can remember. At some point it apparently became fashionable to put your default route at the bottom. Seems kind of silly to me but whatever, as long as I can change it I don't care what the default is.
I had a machine at 192.168.1.1/24 already, which obviously was conflicting with my Airport Extreme. So now I have to re-configure that machine (I have a handful of static machines because they serve various things out to the public and changing firewall rules to match DHCP changes is annoying). To make matters worse every machine on my network that was static was using 192.168.1.254 as a DNS server, so every time I SSH'ed into a machine to re-configure it I had to wait for reverse DNS to timeout.
If Apple made it so you can not change the IP address of the airport extreme I would not be surprised. Apple products are great if you fit into their very narrow use-case. But the minute you try to do even basic things that are normal EVERYWHERE else in the world you end up fighting with Apple stuff. I can point to multiple instances of where Apple products are total failures. This Airport Extreme business is just one example.
posted at: 21:23 | tags: apple, rant | path: /entries/rant | permanent link to this entry
